EOIR / Immigration Court

New York - Federal Plaza Immigration Court — Asylum Decision Statistics

Aggregated asylum decision statistics across all immigration judges currently sitting at the New York - Federal Plaza Immigration Court, based on FOIA-released EOIR data.

Latest 12-month grant rate

13.4%

Asylum decisions, trailing 12 months

Lifetime total cases

198,204

All recorded asylum decisions

FY2024 court average

69.8%

Stable benchmark: Oct 2023 – Sep 2024

Last data refresh

2026-05-19

From Deportation Data Project FOIA release

Monthly grant-rate trend

0%25%50%75%100%

Which immigration judges work at the New York - Federal Plaza Immigration Court?

The table below lists every judge with substantive asylum case volume in the last 24 months at the New York - Federal Plaza Immigration Court. The 12-month grant rate column reflects the trailing year ending 2026-05-19. Lifetime cases counts all recorded asylum decisions for each judge across the FOIA-released dataset.

Judge12-month grant rateLifetime cases
Crawford, Carol A.10.9%1,070
Dandelet, Kyle23.4%1,307
Factor, Samuel M.9.8%1,798
Golovnin, Lena6.3%1,871
Harbeck, Dorothy A.20.9%1,616
Jeannopoulos, Amanda9.8%884
Johnson-Papillo, Carrie C.4.5%1,225
Klahr, Deborah E.5.9%1,712
Little, Anna C.20.1%1,427
Mcfarland, Michael G.20.4%2,061
Nassar, Dania10.7%1,319
Nazaire, Karen0.6%745
Nelson, Barbara A.10.1%6,464
Peal, Tiesha5.3%1,523
Reingold, Jonathan10.5%908
Sagesse, Cathy7.8%1,856
Siemietkowski, John8.5%1,476
Sponzo, Jem C.5.3%2,900
Thompson, Donald W., JR.10.4%3,105
Wright, Virna A.8.8%3,675

Frequently asked questions

What is the asylum grant rate at the New York - Federal Plaza Immigration Court?

Over the trailing 12 months, the New York - Federal Plaza Immigration Court granted asylum in 13.4% of decided cases. The fiscal year 2024 (Oct 2023 – Sep 2024) court-wide average was 69.8%. The two numbers may differ because policy and caseload shifts can move rates significantly year-over-year.

How many immigration judges work at the New York - Federal Plaza Immigration Court?

Based on the most recent FOIA-released EOIR data, 20 immigration judges are listed as actively sitting at the New York - Federal Plaza Immigration Court with asylum case volume in the last 24 months. The full judge roster, each with their individual grant rate, appears below.

How many asylum decisions has the New York - Federal Plaza Immigration Court issued total?

The New York - Federal Plaza Immigration Court has issued 198,204 recorded asylum decisions across the full FOIA-released dataset. This includes both grants and denials but excludes administrative outcomes (cases dismissed, terminated, or closed without a merits ruling).

How is the asylum grant rate calculated?

Grant rate = (cases with case_outcome of "Relief Granted") divided by (cases with case_outcome of "Relief Granted" or "Remove"). Cases closed administratively — dismissed, terminated, voluntary departure — are excluded from the denominator. This is the standard methodology used by TRAC Immigration (Syracuse) and the Deportation Data Project (UC Berkeley).

Browse other US immigration courts

Asylum grant rates vary widely between courts. Compare with these high-volume immigration courts:

Methodology & sources

Primary source
Deportation Data Project (UC Berkeley) — FOIA-released EOIR case-level data.
Secondary source
TRAC Immigration (Syracuse University) — independent corroboration of grant-rate aggregates.
Last data refresh
2026-05-19

Statistical data only. Case outcomes depend on case-specific merits, evidence, and counsel quality. This page is provided for informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice or a guarantee of any outcome.